1972 – Babe Triscaro, Dick Evans and Ralph Perk, Sr.
1973 – John Nagy
1974 – Whiz “Bang” Carter and Ollie Downs
1975 – Mike Scigliano and Jimmy Bivins
1976 – George Pace
1977 – Larry Madge
1978 – Steve Blake
1979 – Vito Mazzeo and Jeff Stoudemire
1980 – Phil Goldstein and Jackie Keough
1981 – Charlie Steward and Max Neidenbach
1982 – Lou Champa, Gene Glen and Johnny Avon, Sr.
1983 – John “Avec” Erjavec and Fred Suess
1984 – Eddie Lee
1985 – Jack Pallat, Calving Butler and John Lawer
1986 – “Buster ” Fredericks, Peter Lawer and Troy Bellini
1987 – Richard Giachetti and Fred Kersey
1988 – Lou Laurie
1989 – Frank Tomaro and Don Gonzalez
1990 – Eddie Marotta, Mike Minnich, Chuck Watkins, Oscar “Sweetpea” Hutcherson and Sammy Derrico
1991 – Eugene Jackson, Richard Stewart, John DiCirco, Rev. Emory Kirk and Carl Gumina
1992 – Clarence Lavaty, Frank Ruskey, Joe Hammett, Larry Johnston and Bobby Giachetti
1993 – Harry James, Murray Reiter, Nicholas Harris, Thomas DeSantis, Charles Pinzone and Donald O. Morrow
1994 – Wylie W Farrier (Posthumously), Robert Ritter, Cobby Caputo, Sal Marino, Dr. Art Kovesdy, Berry Wright and Mike Pipoly
1995 – Al Brooks, Vince Lanese and Merle Haley
1996 – Joey Maxim, Frank Loucka, Mickey Nakon, Steve Kostrubanic, George Whitbread and Anderson Lauderdale
1997 – Joe Gentile, Tony Hughes and Clint Martin,Shamus McCray, Tommy Salmey and Jimmy Timoteo
1998 – Al Heard, Terry Gallagher and Mike Galassi
1999 – Forest Caldwell, Robert Yupa, George Kruichuk and Richard Bellew
2000 – Roland Bagley, Johnny Kilbane (Posthumously), Don King, James Haynes, Tommy Salem, Dick Acton and Frank Trusso
2001 – John Abbott, Pete Quattrochi, Tony Rencic, Stuart Huie and Marty Gray
2002 – Nate Brooks, John Hobart, Jackie Baker, Rasool Akram, Paul Ramos, Jr., and Paul Simpson
2003 – Mike LaQuarta, Earl Jewell, Norm Cooney, James Parks and (Posthumously) John Giachetti
2004 – Kenneth Hill, Marty Healy, Edward Dobrzanski, Tommy Zdanowicz, Johnny Papke (Posthumously), Melvin Callahan (Posthumously)
2005 – Bobby Rivera, Joe Maxse, Tom Huff, Lee Bohles, Sr., Lorenzo Scott, & (Posthumously) Jimmy Trusso and Frank Tomaro
2006 – Bernie Profato, Tom Lorek,Terry Young-Bey, Leo Keglovic, Thomas A. Miller, Bobby Jones & (Posthumously) Nunzio Louis “Babe” Triscaro
2007 – Paul LaBuda, Charles McGhee, Tony Maiorana, Ronnie Tillman William Henry Merritt, Nick Duganier and Vonda Ward
2008 – Don Wagasky, Mike Chase, Cecil Shorts, Thomas J. Rehnert, Paul Bell and Tony Brush (Posthumously)
2009 – Gary Horvath, Don Myers, Abe Herskovitz, Celina Avallone, Ralph Moncrief, Joe Delguyd, Tony Rodriguez, Fred Smith, William Futchi
2010 – Arnold Mitchell, Berry Wright, Lloyd Marshall, Dominic Tomaro, Marc Haire, Nick Pappas
2011 – Corey Gregory, Joe Lenart, Luis Torres, Rick Lazada
2012 – Freddie Bambino, Jim Borgen, Lynn Lustig, Sanderline Williams
2013 – Paul Buckner, Eli Dixon, Joe Santamaria, Leonard Church
2014 – No Hall of Fame Inductees
2015 – Alex Cooper, Terry Strowder, Michael Melbar
2016 – Otha Martin, Jon Melbar, Jackie Davis (Posthumously) Chuck Hunter (Posthumously)
2017 – A. Maserati Riggins, Bryan Gedeon, Carl Burton, and Matt Sysack
2018 – Anthony Greene, Henry ‘Sugar K’ Hughes and Pete Rademacher